Posted: December 29, 2009
Inflation, deflation—pick your poison
But the rise in household net worth is a positive signBy Jeff Thredgold
The debate continues to rage among financial market players and economists as to whether inflation or deflation will be one of the many challenges facing the U.S. economy in coming years.
Vocal critics of the Federal Reserve and the Obama Administration argue that the current mix of monetary and fiscal policy is prone to disaster, i.e. rampant inflation. They suggest that the more than doubling of the Fed's balance sheet from roughly $875 billion before the financial crisis to more than $2 trillion now...all done with newly created money...is the height of irresponsibility.
Adding insult to injury in the eyes of the inflation wary are the unprecedented budget deficits recorded last year, this year, and likely for years to come. The inflation wary suggest that the ownership of gold, other commodities, and real estate are the best places to keep one's financial assets.
A Run of Deflation
The other vocal camp suggests that one need merely look at Japan in the early 1990s for a whiff of what's coming. The bursting of Japan's real estate and asset bubble roughly 18 years ago led to a serious eight-year battle with the deflation disease, i.e. declining prices for assets of all types.
While declining prices for homes, commercial real estate, stocks, manufactured goods, and services might sound like a good thing to many, it is quickly followed by declining incomes. Significant amounts of spending are also delayed as people assume that prices will be lower if they wait longer.
Is this not what is happening in dozens of residential and commercial RE markets today? Potential homebuyers and investors are excited about much greater values in various markets today, where prices have fallen as much as 50 percent, but aren't many waiting for even further declines before they make an offer (with some waiting too long)?
The deflation camp points to soft home prices, declining values of commercial real estate in many markets, major slack in labor markets, and high levels of global anxiety as a menu for deflation in coming years. Their desired investment portfolio favors fixed-rate notes and bonds, especially those issued by the U.S. Government and highly rated companies.
In the Middle
The third view is that we will muddle our way through in regard to inflation pressures in coming years. The Fed will shrink its balance sheet back to more normal levels when financial flows improve by selling assets it has been buying. In addition, bond investors will remain so inflation sensitive that they will force the Fed's hand, if necessary, to tighten monetary policy significantly in order to keep inflation at bay.
We have been here before during the late '70s and early '80s. The Fed responded at that time with a major monetary tightening to fight off double-digit inflation that engulfed the economy. The middle road suggests that the current massive Fed ease of 2008/2009 could be followed in coming years by a significant monetary tightening to corral inflation pressures.
The estimated net worth of the American household rose during 2009's third quarter, following a rise in the prior quarter as well. These increases follow a trouncing of American consumers' balance sheets during the prior two years resulting from the Great Recession.
Net worth increased to $53.4 trillion during 2009's third quarter as a modest gain in home values and rising stock prices contributed to a 5.2 percent jump from the prior quarter's $50.8 trillion estimate. Even so, the net worth of American households would have to climb another 23% to reach the estimated $66.0 trillion pre-recession peak during mid-2007.
Net worth is derived from the Federal Reserve's quarterly flow of funds report. The total represents the difference between all household assets, including stocks, mutual funds, real estate, CDs, etc, minus all debts, including home mortgages, consumer debt, bank loans, etc.
Stocks owned by households rose an estimated $1.04 trillion in value during the July-September quarter. In addition, households cut down total debt at a very slight rate during the third quarter, with reductions in both mortgage debt and consumer credit outstanding.
Consumers have been aggressive, where possible, in paying down debt during the past two years in response to serious recession, painful job cuts and higher levels of anxiety. In addition, the estimated savings rate has run at a 4 to 5 percent annual rate in recent months, the highest level since 1998.
The rise in net worth is a positive sign and will likely be followed by another modest gain during 2009's final quarter. Home values have continued to stabilize in numerous markets, while most major stock averages have risen to their highest levels in more than a year.