Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Eagle County Real Estate: Market Shift Brings New Hope for Buyers 

Buyers looking for homes in Eagle County have newfound hope with the recent summer-selling season market shift. Active residential listings have more than doubled over the past two months, from 150 to 376, with 75 new listings coming to market during a recent one-week period. Buyers now have more options, which typically means less competition, though homes that are priced right, in the right condition and neighborhood are still seeing multiple offers. Let’s take a look at some contributing factors that make Eagle County a prime investment spot for homebuyers.

Interest Rates 

While the rise in interest rates has some concerned, it’s important to keep in mind that even at 5.5%, we’re at the national average. This number got skewed with the artificially low drop in rates during the Pandemic, so this is more of a market correction. The good news is there are contract negotiation options to lower this rate.

Buyers can also work with their broker and ask sellers to assist in buying down the mortgage rate as long as their lender will allow seller concessions. This process allows buyers to get down to the 4% range and away from the 5.75-6% rates currently being quoted from lenders. This can save the buyer a significant amount of money over the course of the loan. 

Interest rates seem to have less impact on luxury/resort market buyers. These buyers still have access to cash, which does better with real estate than in a bank account. Cash offers are still king. Some buyers continue to make cash offers knowing they can get their loans prior to closing on the property.

Pricing 

We are still a little too close to know for certain, but there are indicators that the top of the market was in March or April, so sellers must be careful about their pricing. Shooting for the moon on pricing right now may cost sellers time and money in the long run. Yes, special and unique properties will always garner the highest prices, even in this changing market. However, if the property is similar to the one down the street, the idea of pricing the subject home 10% higher than the last sale may get sellers in trouble. 

What it means for Sellers 

While it’s still a little early to know if we have hit the height of the market, we’re not likely to see the kind of increases we have experienced over the past two years. The shift is really more neighborhood and property-dependent. When a property shows up at the right price, sellers are still seeing multiple offers. Buyers are also gravitating toward properties that are updated and move-in ready vs. taking on the construction, supply chain delays, and costs associated with a remodel.

Gone are the days of ”it doesn’t matter what condition your home is in, it will sell.” If there are deferred maintenance items with your home, it’s important these get addressed. They will come up in inspections and with more options available, buyers have more negotiating power.

With buyers having more choices, sellers need to be cognizant of price relative to condition, location, and market value. The smart seller will work with their broker to price it right and let the buyers dictate the top market value. If there are multiple price reductions within a given segment of the market, buyers are more likely to wait and watch sellers negotiate against themselves with price reductions. The seller that gets to the appropriate price first, in this market, will sell before the others. 

 

Rick Messmer Bhhs
Rick Messmer
Larry Agneberg Bhhs
Larry Agneberg

Rick Messmer and Larry Agneberg are 20- and 40-year Vail Valley residents and award-winning broker associates with locally owned Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties. Their achievements have them both earning the Chairman’s Circle Diamond Award, bestowed upon the top half of 1% of all broker associates nationwide. Messmer specializes in down valley real estate including serving as managing broker for the Eagle office and partner in the Messmer Group. Agneberg is with the company’s Vail-Lionshead office, specializing in the resort/luxury market. They can be reached at [email protected] or 970-376-0041 or [email protected] or 970-376-7100.

Q1 Real Estate Market Trends Report

Eagle County real estate is starting to see a shift in the market to more predictable activity, with inventory levels starting to rise — normalizing a trend that used to occur each spring and into the summer months before 2020 and 2021’s impact.

The likely difference is that the County will probably see less overall inventory come to market and stay on the market because demand for real estate remains elevated.

The first quarter numbers speak to that. Unit sales in Eagle County declined by 25% in the first quarter of 2022 versus 2021, but dollar volume was only lower by 5% , meaning prices continue to hold strong.

Inventory Levels Rise, Demand Remains Strong

Inventory levels eclipsed to 200 units leading into the start of this year’s second quarter, thanks in large part to some new resort construction projects in Avon. Compared to the end of the quarter in 2021, inventory levels are still down about 40%. Pending sales are also down about 15% compared to 2021; but well-above levels in 2020, when uncertainty reigned, as well as 2019 pre-pandemic levels.

What’s the message?

While inventory is expected to grow over the course of the next four months and provide home buyers with more options, prices will likely continue to increase overall.

If there is pressure on prices, expect it to come from our more traditional local market as interest rates, while still historically low, have crept up over the last month. Remember, these headline rate increases are generally for 30-year fixed mortgages. Buyers are encouraged to check out and know their financing options before making an offer if not a cash offer.

What This Means for Buyers and Sellers

Down Valley

Rick Messmer, managing broker for Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties’ Eagle Ranch office, notes that in a typical year, available properties peak in August and properties under contract peak in September. While the expected peak of inventory will not be as high as “normal,” buyers are likely to see more inventory than what is currently available, offering some welcome relief. Moreover, the added inventory may slow the explosive increase in prices recently experienced.

“The massive influx of interested buyers to our market has not ceased all together but is coming in at a rate just a little slower than before. Interest rate increases will also eliminate some buyers as the per-month costs of ownership will preclude them from being able to buy or buy what they want,” says Messmer.

Messmer also notes that to compete in this market, buyers must be ready to jump at a moment’s notice. Down Valley, sellers are still listing their homes and shying away from off-market listings in order to capture the largest possible pool of buyers. Buyers have to be ready to see a new listing within hours and be ready to write on that property immediately if it fits their needs and checks the boxes. This will, if we see more properties come to market, ease as we get into the warmer spring and summer months.

Luxury and Resort Market

Marla Hillerich, broker associate with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties’ Beaver Creek office, notes that for the most part, buyers in the luxury/resort markets of Avon, Cordillera, Singletree, Beaver Creek, Bachelor Gulch, and Vail, still have more choices, if only that there are fewer buyers looking for homes at price points above $2 million.

“The challenge for sellers is that older inventory is harder to command top-of-market pricing due to dated furnishings and overall design,” explains Hillerich. “Presenting a home in the best possible light becomes increasingly important. By adding a more updated look and feel to the property, it will typically attract more buyers. In addition, having high quality photography and videos are imperative. Virtually every buyer will start on-line, and you only have one opportunity to make a first impression.”

Hillerich also notes that new construction projects in Avon are giving the luxury market buyer more options. These new projects, along with other sellers updating their current property, are likely to put more pressure on sellers who have older properties. Hence, the need to do some staging and updates that allow potential buyers to see themselves in a more contemporary setting.

Multiple offers are still prevalent in the $2+ million mark and buyers may need to settle for less than what they initially hoped or bring more money to the table. When priced right, a home is still likely to get multiple offers that are above list price. Buyers should be prepared to come to the table with a strong offer and be able to respond quickly when they find a suitable property.

Interest Rates and Impact

Finally, the other headline word is inflation. The good news for homeowners and active buyers is that real estate has proven to be an attractive hedge to inflation. While this is a decade-by-decade look, it does demonstrate the additional historic value homeownership has to combat macroeconomic influences in the market.

As Messmer states, “Inflation is occurring all around us. We do not know, long-term, where prices will go. If there is a home that meets your needs, and you can afford it, stop paying someone else’s mortgage and begin paying your own!”


1412 E Haystacker Dr Eagle Bhhs Rick Messmer Jennie Longville May
1412 E Haystacker Drive, Eagle: Located at 1413 E. Haystacker Drive in Eagle on an oversized lot in the desirable Highlands neighborhood this 4 bed/5 bath, 3,880 sq. ft. home looks out on to open space and offers the latest in finishes and contemporary, open-air design with an optional lock-off unit. Listed by Rick Messmer and Jennie Longville May with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties. The home sold for $2.12M in March 2022.
207 Osprey Lane Gypsum Bhhs Rick Messmer Laurie Slaughter
207 Osprey Lane, Gypsum: This brand new, site-built, 3 bed/2.5 bath, 1,480 sq. ft., end-unit townhome offers plenty of light and easy access to trails and open space. Located at 207 Osprey Lane in Gypsum, the home includes an attached two-car garage, vaulted ceilings, LVT flooring, quartz countertops, kitchen pantry, and stainless-steel appliances. Listed by Rick Messmer and Laurie Slaughter with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties, which sold for $475,000 in February 2022.
1250 Bachelor Rdge Avon Bhhs Marla Hillerich
1250 Bachelor Ridge Road, Avon: Offering ski-in, ski-out access in the highly desirable Quartermoon neighborhood in Bachelor Gulch, this 5 bed/6.5 bath, 4,247 sq. ft. private residence at 1250 Bachelor Ridge Road offers views of the Gore Range and an open floor plan with vaulted ceilings, stone fireplace, log beams, reclaimed wood floors, remodeled kitchen, and outdoor patio. Listed by Marla Hillerich with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties. The home sold for $6.43M in March 2022.
38390 Hwy 6 201 Bhhs Leigh Rychel Marla Hillerich
38390 Hwy 6 #201, Avon: Located at 38390 Hwy 6, #201 in Avon, this fully furnished 3 bed/3 bath residence in The Ascent, an amenity rich property next to the welcome gates to Beaver Creek, is a southwest facing, brightly lit corner unit. Added owner amenities include indoor heated pool, indoor and outdoor hot tubs, fitness room, sauna and steam room, ski locker, spacious owner storage, heated parking, game room, and a ski shuttle to Beaver Creek and Vail. Listed by Leigh Rychel and sold by Marla Hillerich for $1.43M in February 2022, both with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties.

(Photos and descriptions, courtesy of: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties.)

Michael Slevin is the president of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties, a 51-year family-owned business that has grown to include 12 offices in 10 communities spanning from Summit to Eagle to the Western Slope. It is among the top 50 companies in the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices worldwide network of more than 1,500 offices.

Home Real Estate: Why it’s Still a Good Time to Buy

It’s no secret that inventory levels across the country are, for the most part, at all-time lows and multiple offers on homes commonplace. As a result, one of the most frequently asked questions among buyers is, “should we just wait?”

Waiting, in almost all instances, only creates frustration for buyers in the long run.

In our more than 70 years’ collective experience working with buyers and sellers in the Vail Valley and Eagle County, and watching trends across the country, waiting has not been the optimum way to go.

Yes, Vail and Eagle County — and other resort and popular destinations — have low inventory, yet buyers are finding and purchasing properties with the help of experienced brokers who know where and how to look, and have established relationships with other brokers.

Home ownership in today’s market still outweighs that of renting and not owning at all, even in a competitive market. The pride of ownership, financial benefits of owning versus renting, favorable interest rates, tax benefits, and the ability to live in a mountain or other resort community, continue to be reasons enough to “keep your name in the hat” in becoming a homeowner.

It could be argued that, while the process of purchasing a home has changed in the last year-plus, the benefit of today’s market has been felt by both buyers and sellers and has created more of a sense balance than what the headlines portend.

The question buyers need to ask themselves is, “How long am I willing to wait to enjoy having a place to live in, use, and enjoy?”

Waiting, in almost all instances, only creates frustration for buyers in the long run — as the realization of missed opportunities occurs, increased values take place, and discovering they will still end up competing with all the other “let’s wait and see” buyers for that one property they have waited on in an effort “to see what happens.”

There is only so much supply in the resorts and in Eagle County, and the general consensus is these destinations will continue to experience an active market for quite some time.

The question about “When is the right time to buy?” really comes down to “When you are ready.”

Yes, there are challenges when entering the market for first time, whether it’s the resort/luxury market, or more moderately priced areas. Yet, the increased values, gains, and the enjoyment and pride of new ownership witnessed over the past couple of years has far outweighed the frustration and challenges buyers have experienced.

The question buyers need to ask themselves is, “How long am I willing to wait to enjoy having a place to live in, use, and enjoy,” whether it is for you and/or your family.

Yes, you might have to step up, settle for something less than perfect, not as desirable as you had hoped for and/or lower your expectations. It costs you nothing to speak with an experienced broker who has the longevity and has experienced the ebbs and flows of this market. You can then, make the decision if you should ‘through your hat in the ring.’


Jennie Longville May and Craig Denton, award-winning broker associates with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties, work through some of the common questions homebuyers ask, in Colorado at large, and across Vail Valley and Eagle County.
889 Granite Springs Trail, Edwards: Located at 889 Granite Springs Trail in Cordillera, this custom, 5 bed/8 bath, 11,059 sq. ft. single family home mixes traditional style with Tuscan flare, including heavy trim work, textured wood beams, natural stone, top of the line detailed finishes, vaulted ceilings, wine cellar, expansive kitchen for entertaining and hearth room. Listed by Kevin Denton with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties and Denton Advisory Group for $10M.
Jennie Longville May and Craig Denton, award-winning broker associates with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties, work through some of the common questions homebuyers ask, in Colorado at large, and across Vail Valley and Eagle County.
2610 Beartrap A, Avon: Offering panoramic views Bachelor Gulch and Beaver Creek and back to Vail, this remodeled 4 bed/ 5 bath, 3590 sq. ft. duplex features new wood flooring, carpet, refurbished wood trim, paint, entry way tile, updated lighting and window coverings, and new home office. Located at 2610 Beartrap A in Avon, the home sold for $2.05M in December 2021 by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties’ and Denton Advisory Group Managing Broker Craig Denton.
Jennie Longville May and Craig Denton, award-winning broker associates with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties, work through some of the common questions homebuyers ask, in Colorado at large, and across Vail Valley and Eagle County.
1476 Westhaven Drive, Coldstream Condo Unit 4, Vail: Nestled along Gore Creek and steps to the Grand Hyatt Hotel & Spa, this fully furnished, 1 bed/1 bath, 746 sq. ft. Coldstream condo unit 4 at 1476 Westhaven Drive in Vail offers a rare opportunity to own in Cascade Village and offers all of the conveniences of being within walking distance to the ski slopes. Features include private patios off of the master bedroom and living room, fireplace, and onsite hot tub and pool. Currently listed for $1.35M by Jennie Longville May with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties.
Jennie Longville May and Craig Denton, award-winning broker associates with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties, work through some of the common questions homebuyers ask, in Colorado at large, and across Vail Valley and Eagle County.
203 Osprey Lane, Gypsum: This brightly lit, site-built, new construction 3 bed/2.5 bath, 1,480 sq. ft. townhome in Stratton Flats in Gypsum includes a 2-car attached garage, vaulted ceilings, LVT flooring, quartz countertops, kitchen pantry, laundry room, and stainless-steel appliances. Sold for $475K by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties’ Broker Associates Jennie Longville May and Rick Messmer of the Messmer Group in February 2022. Stratton Flats Development was an affordable housing project consisting of 40 townhomes and 15 single family homes that sold out pre-construction.

(Photos and descriptions, courtesy of: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties.)
Berkshire Authors

Jennie Longville May and Craig Denton are award-winning broker associates with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties in the company’s Edwards and Vail offices respectively. Both are members of the coveted Chairman’s Circle several years running, bestowed upon the top .5% of all Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices brokers nationwide. Denton’s five-year streak also earned him a coveted Legends award. They can be reached at [email protected] or 970-390-6617 or [email protected] or 970-376-0087.